A recent study was conducted and published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine looking at the incidence of patellofemoral pain in over 1500 military recruits undergoing a standard 14-week initial training program. This basic military training program consisted of 3-4 hours of training daily. Past reports have identified that up to 15% of new military recruits will develop patellofemoral pain during the initiation of basic training. This totally makes sense as their workload likely shoots up dramatically and can be used as a great model for the observation of overuse injuries. Just another reason to be thankful for all our troops!
The recruits were divided into two groups, the exercise group and a control group. The exercise group began a very simple exercise program of 4 stretches and 4 strengthening exercises designed to minimize the development patellofemoral pain. These included:
- Standing isometric hip abduction against a wall
- Forward lunges
- Single-leg step downs from a 20cm box
- Single-leg squats to 45 degrees of knee flexion with isometric glute contraction
- Iliotibial band
The strengthening exercises used body weight and progressed from 3 sets of 10 repetitions to 3 sets of 14 repetitions over the course of the 14 week program. The isometric hip abduction exercise began with 3 sets of 1 repetition of 10 seconds and progressed to 20 seconds over 14 week.s Stretches were held for 3 repetitions of 20 seconds over the entire 14-week duration. Strengthening exercises were performed prior to the basic training program, while stretching exercises were performed afterward.
If we break down the exercises, we basically have a few generic stretches, an isometric exercise, and three quad exercises, one emphasizing eccentric lowering and another emphasizing concomitant glute contraction. Pretty simple and basic.
Simple Exercises Can Reduce Patellofemoral Pain
The study intentionally characterized patellofemoral pain vaguely, which was fine with me. Basically any type of patellofemoral pain or anterior knee pain. Results of the study showed that 4.8% of people in the control group (i.e. no exercises) developed patellofemoral pain versus only 1.3% of people in the exercise group, or a reduction of incidence of developing patellofemoral pain by 75%. That is a pretty strong reduction in patellofemoral pain.
What is the Take Home Message?
My first thought after reading this article was, “wow, pretty good results with such simple exercises.” So what is the take home here? Should we all be integrating the above exercises into our programming? No, probably not. My take home from all of this is actually very simple:
By performing even simple exercises, you can have a dramatic reduction in the incidence of patellofemoral pain
That is it. I wouldn’t try to read too much into this article. In fact, I probably would have picked 8 different exercises if I were going to design a program to prevent patellofemoral pain, wouldn’t you have? But the results were still great. We can only imagine what a comprehensive program would do. Perhaps one that integrates more advanced strengthening, more emphasis on the hip, and more emphasis on balance and neuromuscular control?
Regardless, I thought this would be interesting to share and discuss to show that any exercise, even simple, is better than no exercise.
Learn more about the patellofemoral joint by downloading my eBook on Solving the Patellofemoral Mystery, free to anyone who subscribes to my newsletter – fill out the box below: