When is an athlete truly ready to begin running after ACL reconstruction? Twelve weeks after surgery has traditionally been a common target, but time alone tells us very little about whether the knee is prepared for the rapid and repetitive loading involved in running.
A new international survey examined how 177 clinicians make return-to-running decisions. The results showed broad agreement on a few basics, such as knee motion and effusion, but surprisingly little consistency in the use of strength testing, functional criteria, patient-reported outcomes, or the design of the athlete’s first run.
Perhaps the most interesting finding was the disconnect between assessing running and measuring the deficits that matter. More than half of the clinicians reported performing a running assessment, yet only a small fraction evaluated knee kinetics, despite persistent knee-underloading being one of the more consistent findings after ACL reconstruction.
So, are we clearing athletes with the wrong criteria, and what should that first running session actually look like? In this week’s podcast, we discuss what this study tells us, what it cannot tell us, and how we can build a more practical return-to-running process after ACL reconstruction.
To view more episodes, subscribe, and ask your questions, go to mikereinold.com/askmikereinold.
#AskMikeReinold Episode 400: When Is an ACL Patient Really Ready to Run?
Listen and Subscribe to Podcast
You can use the player below to listen to the podcast or subscribe. If you are enjoying the podcast, PLEASE click here to leave us a review in iTunes, it will really mean a lot to us. THANKS!
Show Notes
• Quadriceps Tendon Autografts Are Associated With Increased Short-term Reoperation Rates for Extension Deficit or Pain and Inferior Patient-Reported Outcomes Compared With Hamstring Tendon Autografts
• ACL Rehab Masterclass
• Evaluation and Treatment of the Knee Online Seminar
Transcript
Mike Reinold:
Welcome back, everybody, to the latest episode of the Ask Mike Reinold show. I’m here up at Champion PT and Performance, answering your questions and doing some journal article reviews. This episode is one of those.
So let’s see, we have Dave Tilley, Lenny Macrina, Diwesh Poudyal, Brendan Gates here for you to break down this journal article, but we get the amazing, intelligent Kevin Coughlin to be the one to help us kick off what this article is. But I’ll start by introducing, and then Kev, you can jump in. But the title of the article is “Do As I Say, Not As I Do: Clinician Return to Running Criteria, First Run Characteristics and Running Assessment Analysis After ACL Reconstruction Compared to the Literature.” And this was published in JOSPT Open in 2026, and we’ll have a link to this article in the show notes on the website.
And before Kevin gets started, I got to say, starting it off with “Do As I Say, Not As I Do” really jades the whole article. But Kevin, what did we find?
Kevin Coughlin:
This was a good one. You kind of saw a lot of this out in social media and people talking about it because it’s one of those ones where it just seems so different from what we’re doing compared to the research.
So basically, the purpose was to evaluate real-world clinician practices against published literature recommendations. And this was regarding return to running criteria. So, what are we looking for to say, “Let’s initiate running?” First, run design. So what does that first run look like? And then biomechanical running assessments: are clinicians doing them, and if they are, what are they measuring? That’s kind of what they were hoping to find.
For the methods, this was a cross-sectional, 71-item survey, and it was administered to 177 clinicians. They were multidisciplinary, so it wasn’t just physical therapists. It was PTs, MDs, athletic trainers, strength and conditioning specialists. They had an “other” category, so I was wondering what that might be because it seems like that covered the gamut. But this was from a conference, the Aspetar ACL Conference in Qatar. And I think that’s important to keep in mind because a lot of these clinicians that are going there, I think, are already going to be somewhat forward-thinking. So it might be a little bit of a bias sample size in the sense that if you’re attending this conference, you’re probably very interested in ACLs and you’re probably… Aspetar puts out a ton of good content, so you might be up-to-date on that. And we’ll talk a little bit about limitations more later.
But then, they were comparing the survey findings from these participants. Basically, there were four benchmark papers in regards to the criteria to initiate running that I’ll talk about. But then, for the first run design and the running assessment, there really wasn’t any research out there for them to compare to. So for those two categories, they were more looking at “what are these participants doing?” What are people who are treating ACLs doing for this? More exploratory, and I think just trying to get the ball rolling.
So, in terms of the criteria to initiate, they were pulling from four different papers. And I think the important thing with this, too, another limitation here in my mind is that these were expert opinions from these papers. They weren’t clinically validated, so it’s not like we have amazing research that says, like, from this randomized controlled trial, if we start running with less than 120 degrees of knee flexion, this is what happens versus if you have full motion. So they were looking at patient-reported outcome measures. They recommended the IKDC. Time post-surgery, they wanted to be greater than or equal to 12 weeks. For range of motion measures, they wanted flexion greater than 120, extension at 0 or better, so hyperextension, zero to trace effusion, and one to two on a pain scale. For strength, they wanted, if you did isokinetic testing, greater than or equal to 70% for the quadriceps and greater than or equal to 80% for isometric testing for that. And then, they looked at, functionally, a single-leg hop test. So that’s what they were looking for for that.
So, getting into the results here, what did they find? So the clinicians filled out all this data comparing those things we were just talking about. For the patient-reported outcomes, 36% did not use any patient-reported outcomes. Those that did, the ACL-RSI was the most popular, but this was in contrast to… There’s a little more clinical data for the IKDC for function. ACL-RSI seems to be more of like a readiness-type thing, where your psychological readiness to return to sport. So that was one thing. In terms of the criteria to return to run for time, 29% used time. In those that did, 12 to 14 weeks was the most commonly cited time.
Clinically, there was a very high agreement on having zero or trace effusion for starting running. Range of motion… 48% said that full range of motion, full extension, was required, and then, 38% said that having greater than 120 degrees of knee flexion was required. About half the participants or respondents said that they would do strength testing. Of that number, most had pretty strict standards of being greater than 70% or even greater than 80% symmetry. And then about half of the respondents said that they would look at a single-leg hop test, and only 3% for that were looking at LSI over 70%. So kind of all over the place there in terms of comparing to the published recommendations. But again, those were just expert opinions, so I think that was a little bit of the issue there.
For first run design, this was also all over the place. So what seemed to be most common is that 61% prescribed it in terms of duration. So, those that did said about 5 to 10 minutes was a good place to start for your first run. For distance, 32% used distance. Those that did said somewhere between 500 and 1,000 meters. And then, when they prescribed it, half of them said that they didn’t prescribe a specific speed. The other half said that they prescribed a self-selected running speed. And I thought this was pretty appropriate. So 8 to 10 kilometers per hour was the most recommended, if they did. And that’s somewhere between a 9.5 to 12-minute running pace. So, it’s like a jog essentially, which I think is obviously pretty good.
And then, for running assessment, looking at the biomechanics of running, only about half of the participants, again, did any type of running gait analysis. Those that did, it was most common to just do like a 2D video. Not as many had a 3D video. And then, they were mostly looking at things that are easier to measure with, I think, the naked eye or the 2D video. So, cadence, stride length, single-leg stance, and contact time. And only 3% did any type of kinetic measurement using more of like a true biomechanical analysis. So that was, again, kind of all over the place as well.
So the clinical implications… I think the biggest thing here, when we look at this, is what the authors were trying to do. I think it’s great to just sample some clinicians who are interested in treating ACLs and see, “what are you guys doing, and how does this relate to the research?” Obviously, I think we have a long way to go to all be on the same page. I try to think a lot about why our re-tear rates are so high and whether it’s that or injuring the other side. And I think, a lot of times, it’s stuff like this along the way where we’re either doing things too early, or we’re not all following the same type of recommendations, and that leads to so much variation in when you start these things.
So, I think it’s a good starting point that kind of kicks off a conversation of, similar to our return-to-sport testing that I think we’ve gotten better at as a profession, how do we better start people on their return to running programs? So, I think we have a long way to go, but it was a pretty interesting read.
Mike Reinold:
Awesome, Kev. Great overview of that. And I think the thing that struck me was just how very few things had a high consensus in my mind, right, Kev? What was probably the highest consensus of anything? I’m trying to…
Kevin Coughlin:
I think the biggest thing was just not having swelling and having near-full extension range of motion and little pain. If you were checking those boxes, most clinicians thought that was good criteria to use. And then, you still see time is pretty popular, somewhere between that three to four-month mark being when people are kicking it off. But then, as you get more into looking at the objective criteria outside of that, like the functional testing, it seems to be way less agreed upon how to go about that.
And I would say I felt like some of… And the authors mentioned this… That some of the clinicians’ responses were actually asking more of you from a strength symmetry standpoint than even the recommendations and the research would recommend. So some of them were saying you had to be over 80% symmetry. I just think about a lot of the ACLs we treat, and especially like Lenny’s favorite, the quad tendon, if you’re waiting till 80%, you might not be running for like a year. So I think there’s other criteria we can agree upon as a profession, but yeah, so we’re kind of all over the place. But really, the things we at least agree upon is you shouldn’t have much swelling, like the quiet knee type thing, which I think is definitely a good starting point.
Mike Reinold:
Yeah, I agree. I think we share the main take-homes of the things we do. We don’t use time as a clearance by itself, and I don’t think you should use one metric as clearance by yourself. Like Kevin said, if you have one thing, it’s a cluster of things. We use symptoms and effusion as our barometer of how well they’re doing throughout the progression. I think we do that. We don’t rely on LSI alone. I’m just going through my notes here. I think a lot of these things are pretty good. And this is a big reason why Kevin, Dan, and I came up with that ACL rehab masterclass that we went through, is there’s just so many people that just don’t agree on this, or so many people that don’t have a system in place. We wanted to show our system a little bit.
So, it was good to see some of our system in here. Kind of clicks, but I don’t know, there are other things that don’t. I have a couple things I wanted to kind of talk, but I’ll let you guys jump in first. Maybe Lenny, Brendan, you guys want to jump in here?
Lenny Macrina:
Yeah, I mean, some good stuff in there and it’s expected. You take a bunch of clinicians… We’re going to be all over the place in how we practice. But I think the big things are, I mean, I know everybody’s poo-poo on time, but time is still like a consideration. 12 weeks, I think, is still too early. My head is going more towards 16 to 20 weeks for running, but it depends on the person. It depends on… Most people are going to have full motion at that time. Most people are going to have a little swelling still, but have they handled the workouts that I’ve been giving them? Are they able to do a single-leg squat? Have they been doing some plyometrics, especially single-leg plyometrics, and their knee stays quiet? We start strength testing them. 12 weeks seems like it aggravates the anterior knee, especially for a patellar tendon. If we wait till 16 weeks and we strength test them, are they at 70% or around there? And then we start a jogging program or just a little walk-run program, just to see.
And I think you keep it simple, and if you can do some strength testing and you can observe them weight training… And we’re fortunate to have a force plate, so I can look at symmetry side to side. They’re not cheating. They’re not using a hip-dominant strategy. They’re loading the anterior knee, through getting their tibia to anteriorly translate, things like that. Little clues are going to hone in and tell me that that person is ready and they’re mentally ready. I don’t always do an ACL RSI. I very rarely do one, but you can tell if somebody’s ready to go. They’re chomping at the bit.
And so, there’s little things like that that I use in my practice, similar to what the paper had to say. I think we just are a little bit more specific, and it seems like our ACLs do pretty well with that when they initiate. The last thing I want to do is initiate running, and they start to hurt their knee, and then it’s too early, or they’re gimpy and limping. And now it’s just like, “Ah, why’d I do that?” So they have to be ready, and you got to put them in a good spot to have success.
Mike Reinold:
This is sometimes where I think PTs need to collaborate more with strength coaches, and you could tell this was like a PT survey right here. Gosh, at 12 weeks, man, that first month, you didn’t get much done that first month. They’re a mess. That second month, you’re kind of just starting to clean them up, and then you just got into doing some good exercise and like, “Yay, let’s run.” Especially when we’re talking about not returning to nine months, why do we have to start running at three months? I’m actually glad you brought that up, Lenny, the 16 to 20. I mean, we talk about this with some of our throwers here. If you have time, wait. Gosh, do you know what our strength coaches and even PTs in a good program can do with somebody from week 12 to week 16 or 20 to better prepare them to run? I think that’s crazy.
Lenny Macrina:
I just had somebody yesterday who saw the doc at three months out of surgery, and he cleared her to start jogging, and she said to the doctor, “Lenny says I’m not ready. He’s like, ‘there’s no way I’m running.’”
Mike Reinold:
Oh boy. Oh boy.
Lenny Macrina:
And I’m like, “All right. Well, what did he do to clear you?” And she’s like, “He just looked at my knee, and he said I had full motion, so I was ready to start running.” So I’m like, “All right. Well, let’s go out in the gym and let’s look at stuff.” And so we had to do a single-leg, four-inch single-leg anterior squat, and she couldn’t control it. She couldn’t do it. It was all posterior, couldn’t get the knee… Now, she hadn’t done PT in six weeks because she started a new job. So she’s been doing workouts on her own, but she’s working 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM every day, so she hasn’t really been training. I haven’t seen her. But you can see what’s out there, is that three-month recheck with the doc, you’re automatically cleared to start jogging, and you can see how that story’s going to end.
Mike Reinold:
And that’s what we’re faced with in our field.
Lenny Macrina:
Right, right.
Mike Reinold:
So Brendan, what do you think? What are your thoughts on the article?
Brendan Gates:
Yeah, I just wanted to reiterate… I feel like I lagged out a little, so hopefully you all didn’t already have this covered. But the return to jog is usually more of a mental win for the patient than it is a priority at three months for me as a PT treating ACL. And I think people are raring to go because that’s one of the milestones for them in their head. It feels like, “Oh, I’m getting back to what I was.” But I think it’s worth showing them all this data that we want them to pass, or at least pass most of it, to get them really confident and have them know that we’re confident in them starting a jogging program.
So we know, at 12 weeks, they’re still probably going to be weaker, and they need to get stronger even at 16 weeks. But I do think it’s worth… They’re going to be raring to go. So I think it’s important to tell them, “Hey, you’re really close. Let’s make sure we hit all these boxes first to give you the best chance of succeeding when we do start the program,” versus just saying, “Hey, let’s give it a go and see how you feel.”
Mike Reinold:
Yeah. What’s up, Dave? What do you think about the article?
Dave Tilley:
Just one quick note. I think I learned from you guys with TJs that our goal in the pre-throwing phase for TJ is to over-prepare them more than they could ever be, so that the first day is uneventful. And I think the issue with running is that we don’t think that when someone jogs, they’re unprepared, they’re going to tear their ACL on their first 5 to 10-minute jog. That’s not the concern. The concern is all the secondary stuff that the tissue has not been prepped for, so fat pad, patellar tendon, quad tendon. So, I think the big thing that you guys do well is you do two-handed plyos, one-handed plyos, a really good ramp-up program to know the stress.
And I feel like one of the things that we have to make sure we do, to Lenny’s point, he said, that is I want to know how you tolerate 100 to 20 ground impacts, just very light. So pogo scissor in-and-out, maybe band assisted, very light stuff first, and then, even single-leg stuff, like Lenny said, because I think that that’s more of an indication of how the knee’s going to respond to the things that I’m genuinely concerned about, not if you jog and your LSI is 8% lower than we want, your ACL’s going to just tear the first jog step. That’s not what we’re looking at. We’re looking at all the other secondary stuff. And that’s what I think Lenny was saying, is a lot of people will ramp up, they get excited, they do more than they tell you, and then they get a patellar tendinopathy, and you got to back them off for two weeks. So I think the plyo exposure three days a week, 24 hours in between, that’s really important first before we let them go on a first jog.
Mike Reinold:
Yeah, that makes sense, Dave. I like that thought process. I’d say the only thing that maybe, I don’t want to say I disagree with because I don’t know if that’s right, but one of the big things here about the start of running that they kind of talked about was maybe making it a little bit more individualized. And I think that’s one thing we don’t do at Champion, and I think I like that we don’t do that.
So, at Champion, I don’t think we necessarily focus on having a customized running program from day one. Our running progression is based on biomechanical data, like ground reaction forces, like how the knee handles stress. To me, I think everybody goes through a sequential, biomechanical-based running progression with us. And then from there, you can customize based on where you want to go with that because everybody has to have the basics of the biomechanical concepts built into that.
If you’re worried about somebody being a distance runner or a sprinter or a field or court athlete at the start of a running program, I think we might be getting too far ahead of ourselves. Everybody needs to jog before they run, before they sprint, before they do agility. And then from there, we can customize and get more specific, like maybe somebody needs an add-on month because they need to build up mileage, or somebody needs an add-on month because they need to build on speed. But that was my thought on this whole process, is that not everybody needs a customized approach. I think the sequential, biomechanical model to return to running is a good start. And to us, that’s just how we systemize everything. So those were kind of my thoughts.
So Kevin, thank you so much. Great article. I love articles like that where we get a bunch of different perspectives. We’re not going to all agree, and things aren’t going to have a hundred percent consensus. I’ve never seen one of those studies like that actually do that, but it’s good to get other ideas and to hear what other people are doing. I know I reflected back on how we do ACLs, and I said how much of this are we doing and how much we aren’t, and it makes us better. So, great article.
If you like these journal article reviews, subscribe to the podcast. We’ll keep pumping them out, and we’ll see you on the next episode.




